Comparative Assessment of the Prospects for Hydrogen Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles

Today, road transport is one of the main environmental pollutants. It accounts for more than half of all emissions. In this regard, the issue of developing measures to reduce the impact of cars on the environment is gaining relevance. There are various approaches to solve this issue, but the most promising direction is the use of electric vehicles. It should be noted that we cannot talk about their absolute environmental friendliness, since there is still an indirect impact on the environment.
The paper examines the prospects for the use and disadvantages of two types of electric vehicles powered, respectively, by battery or hydrogen fuel cells. Currently, production of battery electric vehicles is a more popular direction, which is largely due to development of technologies in the field of battery production. At the same time, one should not completely exclude other areas, such as hydrogenfuelled vehicles. Such vehicles are distinguished by good environmental friendliness, which is determined by the nature of the combustion product and the possibility of obtaining this type of resource. However, the use of hydrogen as a fuel for internal combustion engines is not relevant. Development of a car with an electrochemical generator is more promising. Today, a fairly large number of the world’s leading car manufacturing companies are advancing in this direction.
The electric vehicles considered in the work have similar emissions of harmful substances, which, under equal conditions, approach zero. However, both types of vehicles leave a carbon footprint, the bulk of which comes from electricity generation and hydrogen production. The study carried out a comparative assessment of the quality characteristics, carbon footprint and operating costs of electric vehicles with various types of power plants under Russian operating conditions. Based on the comparison, the main advantages, and disadvantages of those types of electric vehicles have been identified. Actions are proposed to increase the environmental friendliness of electric vehicles and solve problems that complicate their operation.

1. Grushnikov, V. A. Smart motorisation. Electric vehicles [Razumnaya avtomobilizatsiya. Elektromobili]. Transport: science, technology, management. Scientific information collection, 2017, Iss. 4, pp. 47–52. EDN: XXZHTR.

2. Khamad, I., Abdullaev, E. G., Butov, A. V. Application of innovative technologies: the example of Tesla [Primenenie innovatsionnykh tekhnologii na primere kompanii Tesla]. Ekonomika i upravlenie: problemy, resheniya, 2022, Vol. 2, Iss. 3 (123), pp. 199–206. EDN: HMFYWQ. DOI: 10.36871/ek.up. p. r.2022.03.02.022.

3. Usmanov, U., Yuldoshev, Q. State of the art of fuel cell technology in automotive industry. Universum: technical science, 2022, Iss. 5–11 (98), pp. 33–40. EDN: JPYCWQ. DOI: 10.32743/UniTech.2022.98.5.13575.

4. Limaev, A. S., Mezin, I. Yu., Vorotnikov, M. Yu., Zotov, S. V. Improving the dynamic characteristics of an electric vehicle through the use of a multi-stage gearbox [Uluchshenie dinamicheskoi kharakteristki elektromobilya za schet primeneniya mnogostupenchatoi korobki peredach]. Science and Technology of Transport, 2022, Iss. 4, pp. 61–67. EDN: DEDEJM.

5. Yusupova, O. A. On the problems and prospects for development of the electric vehicle market in Russia [O problemakh i perspektivakh razvitiya rynka elektromobilei v Rossii]. Transport: science, technology, management. Scientific information collection, 2022, Iss. 2, pp. 38–42.

6. Nazmetdinov, N. R. Prospects for the use of hydrogen fuel in cars [Perspektivy primeneniya vodorodnogo topliva na avtomobilyakh]. Energy and automation in modern society: Proceedings of V International Scientific and Practical conference of students and teachers. In 2 parts. St. Petersburg, May 20, 2022. Gen. ed. T. Yu. Korotkova. Volume Part I. St. Petersburg: Higher School of Technology and Energy of St. Petersburg GUPTD, 2022, pp. 171–174. EDN: WQZVUE.

7. Keller, A. V., Karpukhin, K. E., Kolbasov, A. F., Kozlov, V. N. Analysis of hydrogen use as an energy carrier in transport. International conference on digital solutions for automotive industry, roadway maintenance and traffic control (DS ART 2020). 2022, 012087. EDN: BPBWUP.

8. Kashirin, V. A., Mishchenko, E. V. Toyota Mirai and the principle of operation of a hydrogen engine [Toyota Mirai i printsip deistviya vodorodnogo dvigatelya]. Scientificpractical conference of the Faculty of Agricultural Engineering and Energy Supply, Department of Engineering Graphics and Mechanics, 2017, pp. 159–163. EDN: ZSLQZT.

9. Larin, V. Tesla electric vehicle [Tesla – elektromobil]. Energy: economics, technology, ecology, 2016, Iss. 1, pp. 69–72. EDN: VWHQQH.

10. Dyvak, M., Darmorost, I., Shevchuk, R. [et al.]. Correlation analysis of traffic intensity of the motor vehicles and the air pollution by their harmful emissions. 2018 14th International Conference on Advanced Trends in Radioelectronics, Telecommunications and Computer Engineering (TCSET 2018), Lviv-Slavske, Ukraine, 2018, pp. 855–858. EDN: YBSWRN. DOI: 10.1109/TCSET.2018.8336331.

11. Lagerev, A. V., Khanaeva, V. N. Possible directions for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from power plants in Russia until 2050 [Vozmozhnie napavleniya snizheniya vybrosov parnikovykh gazov ot elektrostantsii v Rossii do 2050]. Izvestia Rossiiskoi akademii nauk. Energetika, 2010, Iss. 1, pp. 50–58. EDN: KZDWMH.

12. Pospelov, V. K., Chuvakhina, L. G., Mironova, V. N. Current trends in global energy policy [Sovremennie trendy globalnoi energeticheskoi politiki]. Moscow, Publishing house «Scientific Library», 2022, 220 p. ISBN 978-5-907497-59-7.

13. Beliy, Yu. I., Teregulov, T. A. Hydrogen energy: advantages and disadvantages [Vodorodnaya energetika: preimushchestva i nedostatki]. Questions of Philosophy, 2016, Iss. 12, P. 8. [ E l e c t r o n i c r e s o u r c e ] : https://scientificjournal.ru/images/PDF/2016/VNO‑24/vodorodnaya-energetika-preimushchestva-i-nedostatki.pdf?ysclid=lp9lm144li339240672. Last accessed 25.05.2023.

14. Prokopenko, A. N., Smirnov, A. A. Production of hydrogen from hydrocarbon raw materials for energy purposes [Proizvodstvo vodoroda iz uglevodorodnogo syrya dlya energeticheskikh tselei]. Bulletin of ENGECON. Series: Technical Sciences, 2010, Iss. 8, pp. 26–33. EDN: NCDSVR.

15. Lesyukova, V. V. Characteristics of hydrogen as a fuel and energy storage [Kharakteristiki vodoroda kak topliva i nakopitelya energii]. Tinchurino Readings – 2021 «Energy and Digital Transformation», 2021, pp. 528–531. EDN: INFIQQ.

16. Limarev, A. S., Somova, Yu. V., Kovalenko, A. O., Ochkova, E. A., Akmanova, Z. S. Analysis of possibilities for reducing the environmental impact of cars on the environment [Analiz vozmozhnostei snizheniya ekologicheskogo vozdeistviya avtomobilei na okruzhayushchuyu sredu]. Modern problems of the Russian transport complex, 2016, Vol. 6, Iss. 1, pp. 47–50. EDN: XHSDSP.

17. Limarev, A. S., Mezin, I. Yu., Vorotnikov, M. Yu., Somova, Yu.V., Moskvina, E. A. Electric vehicle as a prospect for reducing environmental impact [Elektromobil kak perspektiva snizheniya vozdeistviya na okruzhayushchuyu sredu]. Transport: science, technology, management. Scientific information collection, 2022, Iss. 8, pp. 55–59. EDN: VOAYHK.

18. Vorotnikov, M. Yu., Limarev, A. S., Mezin, I. Yu. Comparison of operating costs of an electric vehicle and a car with an internal combustion engine [Sravnenie ekspluatatsionnykh raskhodov elektromobilya i avtomobilya s dvigatelem vnutrennego sgoraniya]. Transport: science, technology, management, 2021, Iss.10, pp. 50–53. EDN: RJDKHU.

19. Filimonova, A. A., Chichirov, A. A., Chichirova, N. D., Raakova, R. I. Electrochemical technologies for hydrogen fuel vehicles [Elektrokhimicheskie tekhnnologii dlya avtomobilei na vodorodnom toplive]. News of higher educational institutions. Energy problems, 2021, Vol. 23, Iss. 2, pp. 104–115. EDN: AZKNEE.

20. Timergazin, A. R., Shcheludyakov, A. M. Road vehicles with hydrogen fuel cells [Avtomobilniy transport s vodorodnymi toplivnymi elementami]. Master’s Journal, 2022, Iss. 1, pp. 111–118. EDN: OHUUQS.