Preview

World of Transport and Transportation

Advanced search

ALLIANCES IN THE SEA SHIPPING MARKET:BENEFITS AND RISKS FOR WORLD ECONOMICS

Abstract

Various forms of partnership of business entities are widespread in the economy. One variety of this partnership is competitive cooperation or coopetition (from the words «cooperation» and «competition»), where competitors without stopping real competition for the consumer, are joining forces in the industrial, scientific, technical, financial and other sectors to reduce costs and improve customer service. The most striking result of this collaboration for all its members is the emergence of a unique competitive advantage over other market players outside the partnership (alliance). The objective of the author is to investigate competitive cooperation at the cargo shipping market as a certain form of partnership, using analysis, evaluation method and economic approach. The author analyzes the differences of competitive cooperation from other forms of business organization. The risks are shown, which are associated with development of alliances at the container shipping market as well as with dual role of such economic unions, when at the same time with maximization of benefits partners have undue pressure on consumers and limit the competitive industry environment. The story of the project of alliance P3 et al., followed by 2M and O3, leads to the conclusion that at international container shipping market there is an objective need for consolidation of operators. However, carriers, cooperating on one or a limited number of routes, don’t interact on other key routes, where new alternative alliances emerge. Consolidation of carriers should not be too comprehensive (to prevent emergence of a dominant player, able to impose its will on a global scale). The presence of national regulatory authorities, linked to certain centers of the world economy, protect the interests of these centers, and thereby contribute to the preservation of competition in global markets.

About the Author

I. D. Kotlyarov
National Research University Higher School of Economics, St. Petersburg
Russian Federation
Ph. D. (Economics), associate professor at the department of finances


References

1. Ménard C. The Economics of Hybrid Organizations // Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics. – 2004. – T. 160. – pp. 345–376.

2. Кириллова Е. В. Антимонопольное освобождение в системе линейного судоходства // Современные направления теоретических и прикладных исследований: Международная научно-практическая интернет-конференция, 19–30 марта 2013 г. http://www.sworld.com.ua/konfer30/602.pdf. Доступ 20.11.2014. Kirillova, E. V. Antitrust exemption in the liner shipping [Antimonopol’noe osvobozhdenie v sisteme lineynogo sudohodstva]. Modern directions of theoretical and applied research. International Scientific and Practical Internet Conference, 19–30 March 2013 [Sovremennye napravleniya teoreticheskih i prikladnyh issledovaniy. Mezhdunarodnaya nauchno-prakticheskaya Internet-konferentsiya, 19–30 marta 2013 g.]. http://www.sworld.com.ua/konfer30/602.pdf. Last accessed 20.11.2014.

3. Munari F. Competition in Liner Shipping // The Hamburg Lectures on Maritime Affairs 2009 & 2010. Hamburg Studies on Maritime Affairs. – 2012. – V. 23. – pp. 3–27.

4. Гиренко Р., Котельников С., Рейт Г., Флямер М. Море волнуется // Эксперт. – 2014. – № 6. http://expert.ru/expert/2014/06/more-volnuetsya/ Доступ 05.06.2014. Girenko, R., Kotelnikov, S., Reyt, G., Flyamer, M. The sea runs high [More volnuetsya]. Ekspert, 2014, Iss. 6. http://expert.ru/expert/2014/06/more-volnuetsya/. Last accessed 05.06.2014.

5. Тихонов С. Контейнерный клин // Эксперт. – 2014. – № 20. – С. 79–80. Tihonov, S. Container wedge [Konteynernyj klin]. Ekspert, 2014, Iss. 20, pp. 79–80.

6. Блокировка регуляторами «P3 Network» побудила Maersk к созданию альянса с MSC // Морские вести России. –2014. – 10 июля. http://www.morvesti.ru/detail.php?ID=27149. Доступ 26.08.2014. Blocking by regulators of «P3 Network» induced Maersk to the creation of alliance with MSC [Blokirovka regulyatorami «P3 Network» pobudila Maersk k sozdaniyu al’yansa s MSC].Maritime News Russia, 2014, 10 July. http://www.morvesti.ru/detail.php? ID=27149. Last accessed 26.08.2014

7. Knowler G. Maersk and MSC to attempt new east-west alliance // Journal of Commerce. – 10.07.2014. http://www.joc.com/maritime-news/container-lines/2m/maersk-and-msclaunch-global-vessel-sharing-deal_20140710.html. Доступ 19.01.2015.

8. Paris C. U. S. Federal Maritime Commission Approves 2M Shipping Alliance // Wall Street Journal. – 0 9.10.2014.http://www.wsj.comarticles/u-s-federal-maritime-commission-approves-2mshipping-alliance-1412842825. Доступ 19.01.2015.

9. CMA CGM signs three agreements on the biggest worldwide maritime trades with China Shipping Container Lines (CSCL) and United Arab Shipping Company (UASC) // CMA CGM official Web site. – 09.09.2014. http://www.cma-cgm.com/news/565/cma-cgm-signs-three-agreements-on-the-biggestworldwide-maritime-trades-with-china-shipping-container-linescscl-and-united-arab-shipping-company-uasc-. Доступ 19.12.2014.

10. Su A. Evergreen Marine joins CKYH alliance // Taipei Times. – 21.02.2014. http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2014/02/21/2003583975. Доступ 26.08.2014.

11. Wackett M. CKYH regroups with Evergreen to fight the P3 and G6 – will CSCL be next to link up? // The Loadstar. – 20.02.2014. http://theloadstar.co.uk/ckyhe-regroups-evergreenfight-p3-g6-threat/. Доступ 26.08.2014.

12. FMC approves Ocean Three but Lidinsky calls for investigation // Port Finance International. – 22.10.2014. http://www.portfinanceinternational.com/categories/regulation-policy/item/1800-fmc-approves-ocean-three-but-lidinsky-calls-forinvestigation. Доступ 19.01.2015.


Review

For citations:


Kotlyarov I.D. ALLIANCES IN THE SEA SHIPPING MARKET:BENEFITS AND RISKS FOR WORLD ECONOMICS. World of Transport and Transportation. 2015;13(1 (56)):100-107.

Views: 401


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.


ISSN 1992-3252 (Print)